The problem isn't really that people post funny stuff. As far as I can see it, the problem is that a lot seem to just post whatever they want to in any given thread. I have never seen so many threads hijacked by strange posts as I have seen these past two weeks.
Seriously, I can see no problem in having a spam thread. I myself have been, and probably still am a heacy spammer. Spam is a major part of the forum culture and has been that for over a year.
Last year we had a big argument about the "rules" for spam, culminating in several of the many of our trademark "Goodbye forever" speeches that we had that year. But we figured out what to do, and made a gentlemans agreement. Gentlemen's agreements are always a nice way to settle things, as long as we stick by them.
Anyway, we concluded that there should only be ONE dedicated spam thread on the front page, and that spam should be limited to that thread. Of course, the odd comment did happen in other threads, and the occasional hijacking of threads also took place. But we had gained a real insight to the fact that some people really do not enjoy spam. And there has to be room for them too...
Since then we have gotten a lot of new members. And new faces are always a nice thing, BUT they do not know of our experiences and the agreements we have made in the past. But they have seen that the ability to spam seems to be an ability that is highly praised among the forum regulars. Not knowing the rules, but knowing that spam is good, has sent the spam has gotten out of control once again.
I suggest that we stick to the old gentlemen's agreement. ONE dedicated spam thread on the front page only! And please, think about what you post. If you posted here with a problem, not being a forum regular, how would you take it, if you had 10 replys the next day but none of them where serious, and most of them where attempts to speak italian, odd jokes and buddy to buddy comments? I would be pissed off, and probably find another place to get some help.
The lesson to learn is that SPAM can be a good thing. It is fun, BUT only when used properly. Don't hijack threads, don't spam in active threads, don't turn threads in to MSN chat sessions, don't use other threads for test-beds to see if you can figure out how to post links or pictures... make a TEST thread god damn it! And remember that anything that is off-topic is bordering on the verge of spam. Because, while you are having fun, someone else is being put off by your behaviour.
I don't want to strike down on anybody in particular, but I can see where Bruno is coming from and I think he is doing a mighty fine job of walking the tightrope - letting us handle things and stepping in when we go out of order.
I think that deleting our dedicated spam thread was probably a bit to harsh, but Bruno has got a point. Keep it real people, we are here to help the new people, not to celebrate each other in a (spam) champagne podium celebration ritual. Let the spam and insanity flow in the right threads... instead of showering everyone that happens to pass by.
It's only after we've lost everything, that we are free to do anything.