On a good day, Barrichello is the faster driver. I could almost guarentee that you will never ever see Montoya showing the sort of raw skill that Rubens showed at Hockenheim in 2000.
The men are totally sorted from the boys on a wet track on slick tyres. This is another case in which we see Schumacher's unbelievable talent.
However, Rubens being the most unlucky driver F1 has seen in recent times, I feel the stats will easily show Montoya to be the better driver, and overall, Montoya is probably more consistant and generally better.
HISTORIC BTCC VIDEOS